Purpose,
Theme and Criteria |
Written purpose
and theme for project and clear criteria for selection. |
Criteria,
purpose and theme present but not clear. |
One aspect
missing and purpose, theme, criteria are not clearly stated |
More than one
aspect missing or not clearly stated |
No evidence of
purpose or criteria for selection |
Annotation:
Selection |
Strong evidence
of evaluation of material based on criteria, purpose and theme with
brief quotes or examples |
Criteria, theme
and purpose clear for selection but spotty or inconsistent throughout
the document |
Criteria, theme
and purpose unclear for more than half of document |
One of three
criteria (evaluative evidence of criteria, theme or purpose) missing or
spotty throughout document with few quotes or examples |
No evidence of
evaluation of material based on criteria and purpose. No examples or
quotes |
Annotation:
Summary |
Brief summary
of the book that suggests relationship to purpose/theme for each book |
Summary
present; relationship to theme and purpose clear, but inconsistent
throughout bibliography |
Summary
present; Unclear relationship to theme/purpose |
Summary
unclear; No relationship to theme or purpose is clear in annotation. |
No summary |
Bibliographic Data and format |
Consistent
format; few proofing errors, all important data present, neatly typed |
One criteria
missing or spotty throughout document |
Two criteria
missing or spotty throughout document |
Three criteria
missing or spotty throughout document |
Inconsistent,
many errors, data missing |